Choosing the best deductible

A quick math + risk guide.

Quick answer

What to check first

• Your state’s minimum requirements (for auto) or standard perils/limits (for home/renters).
• Your budget: what monthly premium you can sustain and what deductible you can pay tomorrow.
• Your risk: how expensive a worst-case scenario would be for you.

A simple checklist

• Write down the coverage limits you want (or need).
• Pick a deductible you can actually pay.
• Compare at least 3 quotes with the same limits.
• Verify exclusions, waiting periods, and claim process.
• Save PDFs/screenshots of the quote details.

Common mistakes

• Comparing prices with different limits (not apples-to-apples).
• Choosing the lowest deductible without realizing the premium jump.
• Ignoring exclusions (water damage, wear-and-tear, certain breeds, etc.).
• Not updating coverage after life changes (move, new car, renovation).

How to save money without harming coverage

• Bundle only if the total cost is lower (verify both policies).
• Ask about discounts you truly qualify for (pay-in-full, safe driver, security systems).
• Raise deductibles carefully after you build a small emergency buffer.
• Review every renewal — rates can drift.

FAQ

Is this the same in every state?

No. Insurance is regulated at the state level. Rules, minimums, and pricing factors differ.

Should I choose the cheapest option?

Only if limits and exclusions match your needs. Cheap can be expensive at claim time.

When should I shop?

Anytime your situation changes, and at least once a year before renewal.

Related guides